Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Analysis of Downey Financial's (DSL) 2007 Earnings

Downey Announces Full-Year 2007 Results: "Downey Financial Corp. (DSL) reported a net loss for 2007 of $56.6 million or $2.03 per share on a diluted basis, compared to net income of $199.7 million or $7.16 per share in 2006."

I'm pressed for time, so I'll give you four very interesting charts, with a brief commentary on the fourth chart.



Downey reports NPAs as a percentage of total assets. But not all of a bank's assets are loans. So, to make the NPA statistic more easily comparable, you can back out Downey's cash, investment securities, FHLB stock, and other assets that are not loans from the calculation.


The graph above shows NPAs as a percentage of only loans.




Suppose that Downey was to go back to reserving 50% of their non-accrual loans. That would require adding an additional $114.9 million to the allowance for losses.

Doing that would have blown out their loss for 2007 from -$2.03 to -$6.16. (27.85M shares outstanding)

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

MGIC Provides Investor Update

MGIC Investment Corporation (NYSE: MTG) announced today that year-end 2007 delinquency inventory was 107,120 loans, an increase of approximately 16,000 loans from the end of the third quarter. Cure rates have continued to deteriorate, resulting in a higher percentage of delinquent loans that become claims, and average claim size has also continued to increase. As a result, the Company expects incurred losses for the fourth quarter of 2007 to approximate $1.3 billion. The Company said its insurance in force at year-end 2007 was $211.7 billion. The Company also said it is increasing its paid loss forecast for 2008 to $1.8 - $2.0 billion.
I'm still short MTG - it's one of my favorite positions. Used the rally in financials today to buy back BKUNA, MTG, MBI puts that I had sold last week.

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Floyd Norris: A Bear's Questions

From a Floyd Norris post called A Bear’s Questions comes an excellent quote from David A. Rosenberg, a Merrill Lynch economist:

Finally, the question must be asked: if the first 7 percent downleg in home prices could manage to trigger …
1. Almost $100 billion in write-downs in the banking sector;
2. A 65 percent year-over-year surge in foreclosures;
3. The highest residential real estate loan delinquency rate in 20 years; and,
4. A 20 percent plunge in S&P financials …
… then what, pray tell, will the next 20-30 percent have in store?
I think this is dead on. There are tons of people out there catching falling knives.

I added new shorts since January 1 as a recession play: HOG, M, F, TIF, CROX. Short the consumer and long SHY and BIL is a great trade in my book.

Monday, January 14, 2008

Downey Financial Restates Non-Performing Assets

From an 8-K filed today by Downey Financial.

"As required for all loans classified as troubled debt restructurings, loans modified as part of our borrower retention program must now be placed on non-accrual status but interest income will be recognized when paid. If borrowers perform pursuant to the modified loan terms for six months, the loans will be placed back on accrual status and, while still reported as troubled debt restructurings, they will no longer be classified as non-performing assets because the borrower has demonstrated an ability to perform..."
More detail at Calculated Risk.

For me, the most interesting thing is not the effect of this restatement, but simply the continued, sharp increase in plain-vanilla non-performing assets (NPAs) from November to December.

Of course, I had a pretty good indication of that last week, thanks to my tri-county survey.

Here's a restated chart showing NPAs before and after the change.


Here's the kicker: "As yet, we have not determined the impact this reporting change may have on previously reported financial statements, if any, but we expect to complete this analysis soon.”

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

December Survey of Downey Financial (DSL) Defaults and Trustee's Sales

Today I updated my Downey Financial (DSL) survey of defaults and trustee's sales for December 2007. It's based on a sample of San Diego, San Joaquin, and Solano counties only. See the footnote for more on how this data is collected. (1)

A "Default Notice" is the first step in the foreclosure process. It is a formal notice to a borrower that they are in default. Lenders typically send them after a couple months of missed payments.

Once the lender sends the default notice, the foreclosure clock starts ticking. In California, the borrower has 90 days from the Default Notice to become current on the mortgage. If not, the borrower receives a Sale Notice and shortly thereafter (unless the borrower pays up) the property is sold at auction/foreclosed.

Then the trustee's deed transfers title to whoever buys it at auction (usually the lender takes it back as Real Estate Owned). This is coded as a "TTEE Deed" in most of the California recorded document systems, and on the chart below.


So, on this chart, the blue portion indicates borrowers who are in arrears, and the red is borrowers whose foreclosure is imminent or has already happened.

Also, because Downey is an option-ARM lender, many of their borrowers are making artificially low, negatively-amortizing payments. This may be temporarily allowing people to avoid defaulting. I expect Downey's default numbers to worsen as borrowers hit loan interest resets and/or max out their negative amortization caps.

(1) Not all counties make this data easily available online (especially in California). Los Angeles does not provide online access, and many of the counties that do have extremely cumbersome interfaces. My surveying method is to count all of the default notices and all of the notices of trustee's sale and trustee deeds during the time period. I do not make any adjustments for notices of rescission of default. I have found this data to be an excellent leading indicator, but no warranty is made as to its accuracy.

Disclosure: Own DSL Puts.

Tuesday, January 8, 2008

CBS Year End Review: Downey Financial (DSL)

Downey Financial was down 52% for 2007 from the time that I initiated coverage on March 15, 2007. (Red S indicates blog posts where "sell" was reiterated.)

In my first Downey post I pointed out how Downey had put together a mortgage portfolio with multiple layers of risk including: limited verification of borrower income or assets; concentration in California; concentration in bubble years; use of mortgage brokers; negatively-amortizing Option-ARM loans.

On April 1, when people were still convinced that problems were limited to "subprime," I noted:

"M&T Bank - which is partially owned by Warren Buffett - is being forced to markdown and repurchase its Alt-A loans. Does anyone think that a bank owned by Buffett does worse underwriting than Downey? What does this imply about the value of Downey's portfolio of Alt-A loans?"
On April 12, I reported on an interesting conversation I had with an Arizona real estate agent:
I asked, "Did you ever have any garbage paper you couldn't push through Downey?" He just laughed.

It is amazing that we both set out, for different reasons and at different times, to find the loosest mortgage lender and independently found Downey.
This April 22 comparison of Downey and New Century illustrated that Downey's portfolio was, in some ways, riskier than a subprime lender's.

On June 12, I found out that hedge funds viewed Downey as a good buy. I pointed out that stated income loans made questionable economic sense for normal borrowers.

During the first week of every month, I release my Survey of Downey Financial Defaults and Trustee's Sales (see October and November). This has proven to be a great leading indicator of the Thirteen Month Selected Financial Data report that Downey releases mid-month.

I'll have the December survey posted in the next few days.

Here are the rest of my Downey-tagged posts. I still own Downey puts.

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Astonishing Inventory in Palm Beach County

From the Palm Beach Post:

In Palm Beach County, the supply of unsold homes - called "inventory" in real estate-speak - has risen to astonishing levels as the housing boom continues to go bust.

"Fifty-five months!" McCabe said.

Actually, there's a 57-month supply - nearly five years - of single-family homes in Palm Beach County, based on the current pace of sales, according to Illustrated Properties Real Estate. The South Florida brokerage tracks listings in the Regional Multiple Listing Service.

Does anyone know what the record is for a market that size?